Your next American Idol prediction
- Thread starter MACKG
- Start date
- Status
Jag-Tig
Member
Last night was bad for everyone. Actually, I liked the last girl...Diana DiGarmo or whatever her name is. She was pretty good and if none of the black folks win, I'd go with her.
I agree with NN, why does George act the way he does? Step and fetch it. He's getting on my nerves. I like his voice, but that song didn't do it justice. Wasn't bad, just wasn't great either. Of the black folks, I guess Fantasia, George and then LaToya. I don't think LaToya helped herself last night.
And why must we be tortured by listening to that redhead boy? has he sang any fast, uptempo songs? Must he make every song into a Frank Sintra song? He was horrible. Sounded like a wounded dog.
Bottom line, it's time for redhead to go!
The final choices just aren't quality in comparison to the other years.
I agree with NN, why does George act the way he does? Step and fetch it. He's getting on my nerves. I like his voice, but that song didn't do it justice. Wasn't bad, just wasn't great either. Of the black folks, I guess Fantasia, George and then LaToya. I don't think LaToya helped herself last night.
And why must we be tortured by listening to that redhead boy? has he sang any fast, uptempo songs? Must he make every song into a Frank Sintra song? He was horrible. Sounded like a wounded dog.
Bottom line, it's time for redhead to go!
The final choices just aren't quality in comparison to the other years.
DonTiger
The One....The Only
SU's Finest '93 said:
Why does everyone love Fantasia so much. I mean she can sing and all but Jennifer Hudson was much better than her to me. Fantasia sounds too nasal to me. Something like Macy Gray just not as bad.
Latoya London is my choice. She has a strong voice with a smoothe sound.
jelli
Music Lover
Fantasia has good stage presence. She draws the audience to her. LaToya by far is the best singer. She just doesn't have that special something that makes her stand out. George well he got bass. I think he can sing. Jennifer had finally got her bearings and she was making a definite run for the title. It would have been interesting to see how it would have played out for her. But I think she had more a theatrical voice than cd/studio voice.
That Hawaiian girl needs to go. She cannot hit those upper notes at all. :shame:
Redhead has been consistently bad since this thing began. I have never voted him.
OF the performances last night....Diana Digarmo was the best.
The bottom 3 in my opinion should be Red Head, Hawaiian Girl, and toss up between Fantasia and George.
That Hawaiian girl needs to go. She cannot hit those upper notes at all. :shame:
Redhead has been consistently bad since this thing began. I have never voted him.
OF the performances last night....Diana Digarmo was the best.
The bottom 3 in my opinion should be Red Head, Hawaiian Girl, and toss up between Fantasia and George.
MsJag4Jag
Moderator
I like Fantasia's voice because it is different. She does not sound like your average run of the mill good singer. If LaToya was singing on stage A and Fantasia on Stage B... I'd pay to go to Stage B.
Now if I had to choose between LaToya and redhead...LaToya would win. She can sing and is pretty and has a beautiful smile...but she does not put much action in it...she just sings.
Jennifer Hudson was theatrical but could probably be taught to FEEL the music another kinda way...She was definitely good...She just looked rather kooky in the face when she sang...but I can live with that.
Now if I had to choose between LaToya and redhead...LaToya would win. She can sing and is pretty and has a beautiful smile...but she does not put much action in it...she just sings.
Jennifer Hudson was theatrical but could probably be taught to FEEL the music another kinda way...She was definitely good...She just looked rather kooky in the face when she sang...but I can live with that.
Jag-Tig
Member
Well, we've all seen that being named American Idol doesn't carry that much weight now. This past year you couldn't tell if Rueben won it or if Clay won. That's sad.
So, Jennifer will get her opportunity, I'm sure. If there's an audience for Clay, there's one for Fantasia, George, etc. Whoever gets voted off tonight (probably one of our little brown children), they will still be able to capitalize on making it this far. It's the exposure. The music industry and the folks in Hollywood know how to find talent.
Something tells me that the DiGarmo girl might win this whole thing. Of the non-brown folks, she's the best to me. And since they won't be giving the title to any of the black people, she's the safest choice.
PLEASE, PLEASE let the little redhead boy be gone tonight. I hope we'll be on here tomorrow and talk about how we're glad he was voted off... :cry:
So, Jennifer will get her opportunity, I'm sure. If there's an audience for Clay, there's one for Fantasia, George, etc. Whoever gets voted off tonight (probably one of our little brown children), they will still be able to capitalize on making it this far. It's the exposure. The music industry and the folks in Hollywood know how to find talent.
Something tells me that the DiGarmo girl might win this whole thing. Of the non-brown folks, she's the best to me. And since they won't be giving the title to any of the black people, she's the safest choice.
PLEASE, PLEASE let the little redhead boy be gone tonight. I hope we'll be on here tomorrow and talk about how we're glad he was voted off... :cry:
SONNY
The Future of Omega!!!!
:lol: not Lawrence Welk????
Im so glad that Ofay is gone. He was horrible.
Even though they got rid of him 3 weeks too late, glad he's off.
I honestly think that the producers had something to do with Jennifer getting kicked off. They didnt want 3 DIVAS to blow their white production.
Im telling yall now, it will be the Hispanic young girl against Fanstia in the end. She is the closest thing to being "NON-Black". George huff or the Hawaiian girl are next to go.
Im so glad that Ofay is gone. He was horrible.
Even though they got rid of him 3 weeks too late, glad he's off.
I honestly think that the producers had something to do with Jennifer getting kicked off. They didnt want 3 DIVAS to blow their white production.
Im telling yall now, it will be the Hispanic young girl against Fanstia in the end. She is the closest thing to being "NON-Black". George huff or the Hawaiian girl are next to go.
DonTiger
The One....The Only
Hooray
Finally justice is served and the red-head exists stage left.
Is it just me or was it kinda sad to see him booted off though. I mean, he's only 16 and he's so cool and calm. Even though it was long overdue, it was kinda sad to see the disappointment in his eyes.
Oh Well !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
George Huff is the next to go. The only thing that will save him is a horrible performance by the hawain girl.
Finally justice is served and the red-head exists stage left.
Is it just me or was it kinda sad to see him booted off though. I mean, he's only 16 and he's so cool and calm. Even though it was long overdue, it was kinda sad to see the disappointment in his eyes.
Oh Well !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
George Huff is the next to go. The only thing that will save him is a horrible performance by the hawain girl.
MsJag4Jag
Moderator
Re: Hooray
Don Tiger: It was sad to see Lawerence Welk leave because of his age. But he took it like a man. Ryan Seacrest asked him what will his miss the most and he pointed at the group and said "them"... You could have bought me for a tomato. I felt bad for him. But I was glad he is gone. His is not a popstar. IF he was in a competition to do some Perry Comeaux type stuff...then yeah. He could do it with a little tweaking.
Don Tiger: It was sad to see Lawerence Welk leave because of his age. But he took it like a man. Ryan Seacrest asked him what will his miss the most and he pointed at the group and said "them"... You could have bought me for a tomato. I felt bad for him. But I was glad he is gone. His is not a popstar. IF he was in a competition to do some Perry Comeaux type stuff...then yeah. He could do it with a little tweaking.
MACKG
a.k.a. NASTYNUPE
Re: Hooray
I just don't see Fantasia winning. I'm down with Latoya London now. It's gonna be out of her and the white girl. Seems like they're starting to push her. You can't have two black people as the finalists. It would be bad for ratings. But I commend Fox for creating the controversy by getting rid of Jennifer. They had 28 million votes this week. You know it was rigged. They didn't even let Jennifer sing her song when she got voted off. They let the red head stumble through his. I like the fact that Latoya doesn't front like she's actually sad to see a person leave. She never hugs them. This is a competition. She's a star!!!
I just don't see Fantasia winning. I'm down with Latoya London now. It's gonna be out of her and the white girl. Seems like they're starting to push her. You can't have two black people as the finalists. It would be bad for ratings. But I commend Fox for creating the controversy by getting rid of Jennifer. They had 28 million votes this week. You know it was rigged. They didn't even let Jennifer sing her song when she got voted off. They let the red head stumble through his. I like the fact that Latoya doesn't front like she's actually sad to see a person leave. She never hugs them. This is a competition. She's a star!!!
Jag-Tig
Member
Yeah, I'm kinda with DT and J4J, even though I was sick of that boy, it was a little sad because he's so young. But I'm SO GLAD he's gone!!!
And George standing over there crying. There are ways for a black man to cry and who emotion when you're on national tv. You didn't see Big Rube crying...he might have shown emotion and teared up a little when folks were being voted off, but he wasn't standing back there wiping his tears with the back of his hands like a three-year old. Send George some help please.
Yeah, DeGarmo is definitely in it until the end. I actually wouldn't mind if she won, if a black person doesn't end up winning. The rest is a toss-up. Whoever the producers think can bring in good ratings basically.
And is it just me, or has Randy's lips gotten darker as this show has progressed? I know he had that stomach stapling thing, so many his body is rejecting it. But, he looks like he's wearing way too much make-up or something. His lips are gray and it looks like they put make-up on them. Ugh. Maybe it's just me...I always see weird stuff like that.
And George standing over there crying. There are ways for a black man to cry and who emotion when you're on national tv. You didn't see Big Rube crying...he might have shown emotion and teared up a little when folks were being voted off, but he wasn't standing back there wiping his tears with the back of his hands like a three-year old. Send George some help please.
Yeah, DeGarmo is definitely in it until the end. I actually wouldn't mind if she won, if a black person doesn't end up winning. The rest is a toss-up. Whoever the producers think can bring in good ratings basically.
And is it just me, or has Randy's lips gotten darker as this show has progressed? I know he had that stomach stapling thing, so many his body is rejecting it. But, he looks like he's wearing way too much make-up or something. His lips are gray and it looks like they put make-up on them. Ugh. Maybe it's just me...I always see weird stuff like that.
MsJag4Jag
Moderator
Jag-Tig said:
way off... :topic:
Let George cry. It is ok to show emotion. It means you're human and this is how many black men get confused. On one hand some of us want them to show emotions and share them with us and on the other hand they don't want to seem UN-manly by showing emotion. :lol: So let ol' Georgie Porgie cry.
Jag-Tig
Member
J4J said:way off... :topic:
Let George cry. It is ok to show emotion. It means you're human and this is how many black men get confused. On one hand some of us want them to show emotions and share them with us and on the other hand they don't want to seem UN-manly by showing emotion. :lol: So let ol' Georgie Porgie cry.
but does he have ta cry like a girl? :whine:
You are right though...I guess our brothas are confused...do we want a man who can cry and show emotion or one who doesn't know how? Hmmm...
Poor George. He'll be aw'right. I forgot...how old is he anyway?
- Status