http://www.detnews.com/2003/schools/0302/19/e01-89021.htm
Wednesday, February 19, 2003
John T. Greilick / The Detroit News
Dearborn High School junior Bretton Barber was told Monday to turn his shirt inside out, take it off or go home. He decided to go home rather than surrender his freedom of expression.
Student gets sent home over his anti-Bush T-shirt
Free speech debate in Dearborn
By Karen Bouffard / The Detroit News
Anti-war expression
A Dearborn High School student was sent home from school for wearing a T-shirt displaying an anti-war message, because of concerns that the shirt could spark tensions in a district where more than 50 percent of students are Arab-American. Did the school make the right call?
DEARBORN -- A Dearborn High School junior was sent home from school this week for wearing a T-shirt emblazoned with an anti-war message.
Bretton Barber, 16, said he wanted to express his opinion Monday when he wore a T-shirt he bought over the Internet that shows a picture of President Bush and reads, "International Terrorist."
Concerned the shirt could spark tensions in a district where more than 50 percent of students are Arab-American, school officials told Barber to turn the shirt inside out, take it off or go home.
Barber said he decided to go home rather than surrender his freedom of expression. He returned to school Tuesday without the shirt.
"Bush has already killed over 1,000 people in Afghanistan -- that's terrorism in itself," said Barber, noting he wore the shirt for a presentation he made that morning in English class. The assignment was to write a "compare and contrast" essay -- and he chose to compare Bush with Saddam Hussein.
Dearborn Public Schools spokesman Dave Mustonen said students have the right to freedom of speech and expression, but educators are sensitive to tensions caused by the conflict with Iraq.
"It was felt that emotions are running very high," said Mustonen. "The shirt posed a potential disruption to the learning environment at the school. Our No. 1 obligation is to make sure we have a safe learning environment for all of the students."
Mustonen said the incident had nothing to do with the many Arab-Americans in the 17,600-student district.
Officials said they don't know how many Arab-American students are enrolled in the district, but in 2000, they estimated the figure at about 55 percent.
Imad Hamad of the American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee thinks school officials took the right approach. He hopes they'll take it one step further and use the experience to educate students on how to exercise freedoms in positive ways.
"I see no winner here," Hamad said. "The school did the right thing to diffuse any potential conflict among the student population. I assume they would do the same thing if another message was displayed that was offensive to a different culture.
"Sometimes our very precious freedom of speech is used to justify spreading hatred or to display our bigotry. I see this as a good opportunity for the school to guide students through this issue or to help our youngsters to understand our tough circumstances and to encourage them in positive and constructive debate."
Junior Lindsey Hoganson, 16, thinks students can handle discussions about today's political climate without passions rising. She disagrees with the school's decision not to allow the shirt.
"I didn't hear anybody say anything about the shirt until we heard the administration was making him change it," she said. "A lot of people are worried about the war. We talk about it at school a lot. Talking about it isn't going to disturb the learning environment, because the topic's already been brought up in school. (Barber) was just giving people a different way of looking at it."
Barber's parents support their son's decision to express his views at school.
"It didn't cause any problems at the school, and I think he has a right to wear his T-shirt," said his mom, Tricia Barber.
Barber said he isn't giving up on expressing his views.
"I'm putting a group together at the high school, and working on putting a march together," he said. "It's hard to do it through the school because you need a teacher to support it, but I'm going to try."
You can reach Karen Bouffard at (313) 561-9646 or kbouffard@detnews.com.
Wednesday, February 19, 2003
John T. Greilick / The Detroit News
Dearborn High School junior Bretton Barber was told Monday to turn his shirt inside out, take it off or go home. He decided to go home rather than surrender his freedom of expression.
Student gets sent home over his anti-Bush T-shirt
Free speech debate in Dearborn
By Karen Bouffard / The Detroit News
Anti-war expression
A Dearborn High School student was sent home from school for wearing a T-shirt displaying an anti-war message, because of concerns that the shirt could spark tensions in a district where more than 50 percent of students are Arab-American. Did the school make the right call?
DEARBORN -- A Dearborn High School junior was sent home from school this week for wearing a T-shirt emblazoned with an anti-war message.
Bretton Barber, 16, said he wanted to express his opinion Monday when he wore a T-shirt he bought over the Internet that shows a picture of President Bush and reads, "International Terrorist."
Concerned the shirt could spark tensions in a district where more than 50 percent of students are Arab-American, school officials told Barber to turn the shirt inside out, take it off or go home.
Barber said he decided to go home rather than surrender his freedom of expression. He returned to school Tuesday without the shirt.
"Bush has already killed over 1,000 people in Afghanistan -- that's terrorism in itself," said Barber, noting he wore the shirt for a presentation he made that morning in English class. The assignment was to write a "compare and contrast" essay -- and he chose to compare Bush with Saddam Hussein.
Dearborn Public Schools spokesman Dave Mustonen said students have the right to freedom of speech and expression, but educators are sensitive to tensions caused by the conflict with Iraq.
"It was felt that emotions are running very high," said Mustonen. "The shirt posed a potential disruption to the learning environment at the school. Our No. 1 obligation is to make sure we have a safe learning environment for all of the students."
Mustonen said the incident had nothing to do with the many Arab-Americans in the 17,600-student district.
Officials said they don't know how many Arab-American students are enrolled in the district, but in 2000, they estimated the figure at about 55 percent.
Imad Hamad of the American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee thinks school officials took the right approach. He hopes they'll take it one step further and use the experience to educate students on how to exercise freedoms in positive ways.
"I see no winner here," Hamad said. "The school did the right thing to diffuse any potential conflict among the student population. I assume they would do the same thing if another message was displayed that was offensive to a different culture.
"Sometimes our very precious freedom of speech is used to justify spreading hatred or to display our bigotry. I see this as a good opportunity for the school to guide students through this issue or to help our youngsters to understand our tough circumstances and to encourage them in positive and constructive debate."
Junior Lindsey Hoganson, 16, thinks students can handle discussions about today's political climate without passions rising. She disagrees with the school's decision not to allow the shirt.
"I didn't hear anybody say anything about the shirt until we heard the administration was making him change it," she said. "A lot of people are worried about the war. We talk about it at school a lot. Talking about it isn't going to disturb the learning environment, because the topic's already been brought up in school. (Barber) was just giving people a different way of looking at it."
Barber's parents support their son's decision to express his views at school.
"It didn't cause any problems at the school, and I think he has a right to wear his T-shirt," said his mom, Tricia Barber.
Barber said he isn't giving up on expressing his views.
"I'm putting a group together at the high school, and working on putting a march together," he said. "It's hard to do it through the school because you need a teacher to support it, but I'm going to try."
You can reach Karen Bouffard at (313) 561-9646 or kbouffard@detnews.com.
