ESPN names All-Time All America team in honor of 150 years of college football

[In_The_662]

We know the HBCU player who made the first team. Surprised that Walter Payton didn't at least get 2nd team

View: https://twitter.com/Ivan_Maisel/status/1210200257507790849

 

[Herbert77060]

Hmmmmm

 

[jag4life]

We know the HBCU player who made the first team. Surprised that Walter Payton didn't at least get 2nd team

View: https://twitter.com/Ivan_Maisel/status/1210200257507790849

Looking at the picks though who would he beat out?

 

[Herbert77060]

Looking at the picks though who would he beat out?

Herschel and Griffin. And how is Manning on the list when he could not beat out Tee Martin?

 

[In_The_662]

Herschel and Griffin. And how is Manning on the list when he could not beat out Tee Martin?

Let me put it like this. Most would agree that Jim Brown is safe without any question. Everyone else is debatable but people are gonna play the "level of competition" cards but the number of HOFs from that team should squash all that. 65 career TDs is great no more what level you play at (and during his time it's debatable that those teams could play with the "big boys")

And Manning was a no doubt media darling pick. You could make better cases for McNair, Totten or Doug Williams over Peyton

 

[jag4life]

Herschel and Griffin. And how is Manning on the list when he could not beat out Tee Martin?

Manning never got beat out by Tee Martin lol

 

[Herbert77060]

Manning never got beat out by Tee Martin lol

Tee Martin started over Manning and won a national championship....something Manning never did.

 

[JSUTigers1877]

Tee Martin started over Manning and won a national championship....something Manning never did.

Manning was gone to the NFL when Tennessee won in 1998 under Tee Martin

 

[GRAM4LIFE]

this list is mostly nostalgia

 

[Brave]

I don't agree with the Manning as second team
I'd go with McNair

 

[Kendrick]

How the heck is Roger Staubach the First Team QB?

 

[GRAM4LIFE]

How the heck is Roger Staubach the First Team QB?

Exactly

 

[SoloMan]

Looking at the picks though who would he beat out?

Archie Griffin

 

[Herbert77060]

Manning was gone to the NFL when Tennessee won in 1998 under Tee Martin

Are you sure?

 

[Herbert77060]

How the heck is Roger Staubach the First Team QB?

Media darling like Manning

 

[Mrwiregrass]

This list was made by Tim Tebow.

 

[Kendrick]

Are you sure?

Manning was a rookie on the Colts then.

 

[Herbert77060]

Manning was a rookie on the Colts then.

My bad. Tee Martin won a national championship.....Manning did not.